The Great Mystery Pizza Case: Did Lunchbox Really Make Amy Move Houses?
A news story about a man arrested for ordering hundreds of pizzas and having them sent to random addresses across the country brought back one of the strangest sagas in Bobby Bones Show history — the case of Amy's mystery pizzas, an unsolved prank that, according to Amy, actually changed the course of her life.
How It Started
Years ago, pizzas started showing up at Amy's house. Not once — at least three times, from different pizza places, always paid for, always unordered. The first time it happened, Amy assumed her husband must have ordered it. He hadn't. She tossed it. It happened again. Same result.
Then things got stranger: a letter showed up in her mailbox, unrelated to the pizzas but close enough in timing that it rattled her. Combined with her husband's military background and upcoming deployment to Afghanistan, Amy said she started feeling watched — and didn't want to be alone in that house anymore.
The Fallout: A Move, a Rental, and a Rough Year
The pizza mystery didn't just spook her — it uprooted her entire life. Amy and her husband ended up renting out their house and moving into a condo building with restricted access, specifically so no one — pizza delivery included — could get to them. They lived there for about a year before eventually buying a new house, one that, notably, wasn't even in their names, just to stay untraceable.
Amy didn't hold back on how that stretch of limbo affected her marriage, calling it one of the worst years of their relationship. Whether that specific year gets pinned on the pizza chaos or not, she's clear on one thing: her whole life changed because of it.
So... Who Did It?
Nobody has ever confessed. Over the years, suspicion has bounced around:
- Former radio friends who worked at the station at the time — known pranksters with a track record (including once planting an egg in the studio that sat there, unnoticed, for two years). They've denied it every time they've been asked.
- Lunchbox, who became the prime suspect of the day after a series of tells — quick deflections, uncontrollable smiling, and a very telling moment where he answered a question about whether the pizzas were paid for before anyone had even asked him. Amy herself jokingly "rested her case" right there.
By the end of the conversation, the show landed on rough odds: Lunchbox at 40%, former radio co-workers at 25%, the actual pizza-scheme guy from the news story at 0% (too long ago to make sense), and the rest left open to a mystery suspect.
Lie Detector Test, Anyone?
Things escalated into a bit — suggesting Lunchbox should take a polygraph to clear his name, Bobby, Eddie, & Ray all offering to do the same as a control, and even Scuba (who wasn't even working at the station back then) getting roped in "just in case." The show floated actually looking into the cost of bringing in a lie detector to settle it once and for all.
Whether or not the mystery ever gets solved, one thing's for sure — Amy's pizza saga remains one of the show's most talked-about unsolved cases, and Lunchbox's reaction today didn't do him any favors.
Think you know who sent the pizzas? Call or leave a voicemail for the show at 877-77-BOBBY.
Never miss any of the fun! Follow us on social, listen to The Bobby Bones Show LIVE every morning on radio stations nationwide and on demand on the free iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Hit us up on The Bobby Bones Show on Instagram
Join the conversation with The Bobby Bones Show Facebook Community
Watch all the funny moments on The Bobby Bones Show YouTube Channel